Monday, June 02, 2008

Mad cows and electric fans

Below is a picture from the BBC of a clash between riot police and protestors near Korea's Blue House (the counterpart to the US White House).

 

What was the cause of the violence?  Was it an unjust war?   No.

 

Were the protestors fighting for civil rights?  Nope.

 

Was the mob protesting an election fraud or coup?  Uh uh.

 

They are protesting beef.  Seriously. 

I am disappointed in South Korea's common sense.  The issue of US beef imports, which are cheaper and of better quality than domestic beef, has been brewing for some time.  This hysteria has been fueled over an irrational fear of mad cow disease.

Teens have been the most visible force behind this movement to continue the ban on US beef.  There have been several high-profile and well-attended candle light vigils protesting the resumption of beef imports next week.  The campaigning by teens was driven by SMS and instant messages.  I can understand teens being caught up with an issue that has been tied to nationalism and deemed important.

These teens have been flooding message boards with such politically emo comments as, “Are we fated to die so young?” and “I just want to live and fulfill my career dreams, not die mad like an American cow."

These statements have found their way onto Youtube.  One of the most ridiculous is the following video.  My favorite quotes are:

IS THIS ANOTHER US FORIEGN POLICY OF INVADING THE WORLD?  IRAQ FOR NUCLEAR WEAPON AND SOUTH KOREA FOR MAD COW DISEASE?  WHY KOREAN GOVERNMENT IGNORE OUR VOICES, DO NOTHING TO STOP THIS? [sic]

and

WHAT IS U.N. DOING?  WHY DONT THEY INTERVENE TO THIS POSSIBLE MASSIVE GENOCIDE FROM HAPPENING? [sic]

Genocide?  Seriously?  One commenter on the above video noted, "mad cow is the new fan death."  I had to look it up.  Korean urban legend says that fans left on overnight will cause death.  I always wondered why Korean fans had a shut-off timer built in.  Korean news programs even keep a running tally as they report each "fan death" the occurs.  The problem is there isn't science to back it up.

The same is true with this mad cow hysteria.  I thought adults would not be so gullible, but as that first picture shows, the mob has proved me wrong.  The fact is, that this whole movement is really just economic protectionism under the guise of a public health issue.  Korean beef farmers wouldn't be able to compete with US beef.  So, they are trying to bring up these irrational health concerns.

Here are some reasons why this fear is ridiculous:

1.  If you don't want to eat American beef, then don't buy it!  In Korea, beef is clearly labeled as being domestically or foreign produced.  Currently, most foreign beef comes from Australia.  Koreans can vote with their won.

2.  The US has about 100,000,000 cows.  There have been 3 cases of mad cow.  So, for every cow that was found to have mad cow 33,333,333 don't have it.

3.  The US has a human population of over 300,000,000.  There have been 3 cases of vCJD, the human counterpart of mad cow.  That's a 1 to 100,000,000 ratio.  Even the UK, with more than 100,000 cases of mad cow had only 163 human cases, which works out to be .0000027% of their population.

4.  Koreans are far more likely to be hit by a car than come come to harm from mad-cow tainted beef.  As I've noted before, the child traffic accident fatality rate for Koreans is the highest in the industrialized world.  Why isn't the mom starting a campaign for parents to buckle their kids in the car instead of focusing so much attention on such a silly concern?

I'm confident that beef imports will resume as scheduled, and that in time, Koreans will begin to appreciate the quality and price of US beef.  I plan on eating pounds and pounds of US beef a week just as soon as I can get my hands on it.  And I'll continue to defy fan death by sleeping with the fan blowing in my face, and with the air conditioner on at the height of summer.  I know I'll be fine, but I'm just a little worried  to see what the mob will focus its irrationality on next. 

2 comments:

  1. Wrong, wrong and wrong.

    It's NOT just beef. Have you been down there? Listened to the chants? Seen the posters?

    It's all about a president who is pushing through all kinds of policies that are unpopular. The FTA/beef deal is only part of that. There's the canal, which is just an expensive "gift" to Lee's business buddies.

    There's portal regulation.

    There's privatization of healthcare and water works.

    It's all that... and more.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You seem to have recieved your talking points from the "ohmynews" opinion titled, "Why Are the Korean People So Angry?"

    My facts are correct. The rally in the photo was organized by "The People’s Countermeasure Council against the Full Resumption of Imports of U.S. Beef Endangered with Mad Cow Disease." Other issues may have been brought up, but mad cow as certainly the main topic of the protests.

    The grand canal was put on hold last week.

    The portal regulation is an issue that was brought up by the Fair Trade Commission based on monopoly accusations not as some form of censorship.

    Either way, both of the above issues, really are non-issues now.

    ReplyDelete

I appreciate comments. If you have a personal message to me, then e-mail would be best.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...